DARK BULB
FR

← Tous les articles

Puzzle of the week: who took the apple pie?

Cet article n’est pas encore traduit. Voici la version originale (English).

No explainer this week, just a puzzle. Grab a pen and paper (or just your head) and go find the culprit.

The case

An apple pie sits on the kitchen counter of a house. Four pets live there: a cat, a dog, a rabbit and a parrot. When the pie disappeared, each pet was in a different room. The rooms are the kitchen, the garden, the attic and the hallway. Each room held exactly one pet.

The pie was in the kitchen, so only the pet in the kitchen can have taken it.

Here is what we know:

  1. The cat is not in the attic.
  2. The rabbit is not in the attic.
  3. The dog is not in the attic.
  4. If the parrot is in the attic, then the cat is in the hallway.
  5. If the dog is in the kitchen, then the parrot is in the hallway.

Question: which pet is in which room, and who took the pie?

A hint

Start with the room that needs the fewest clues. And remember that an “if…then…” also works the other way round: if the “then” part is false, the “if” part can’t be true either.

Spoilers below

Got it already? Only then scroll on. It’s more fun when the click is yours.

Solution

Step 1. Clues 1, 2 and 3 rule out the cat, the rabbit and the dog for the attic. Only one pet is left: the parrot is in the attic.

Step 2. Now the “if” of clue 4 applies, so the cat is in the hallway.

Step 3. Look at clue 5. If the dog were in the kitchen, the parrot would have to be in the hallway. But the parrot is in the attic. So the dog is not in the kitchen.

Step 4. The hallway and the attic are taken. The dog can’t be in the kitchen, so the dog is in the garden.

Step 5. The kitchen is what’s left for the rabbit.

So: the cat is in the hallway, the dog in the garden, the rabbit in the kitchen and the parrot in the attic. The rabbit took the pie.

No other arrangement fits all five clues. We also checked this with a small computer program: it tried all 24 possible arrangements, and exactly one survives.

Why this works

A puzzle like this runs on two simple tricks: elimination (what can’t be?) and turning it around (if the consequence is false, the assumption must be false too). You never have to guess, and that is the whole idea of a fair logic puzzle: all the information is on the table.

Want more cases like this? Play Petuko’s first case for free in your browser.

Newsletter

Soyez les premiers informés

Nouveaux jeux, bêtas et résultats du sondage. Un e-mail par mois au maximum.

Nous envoyons d’abord un e-mail de confirmation. Désinscription possible à tout moment, en un clic. Politique de confidentialité