Stuck? Try the "what if" trick
Esta entrada aún no está traducida. Abajo está la versión original (English).

You stare at a puzzle and not a single clue gives you anything certain. Time for the trick we use most ourselves: what if?
How it works
You pick a possibility you are not sure about and pretend it is true. Then you follow the consequences. If a contradiction turns up somewhere, your assumption could never have been true, and you can cross it off. That is not guessing: you use the puzzle itself to prove an option impossible.
The nice part is that you do not have to remember much. You try one thing, see it go wrong, and you have one more certainty.
A small example
A cookie is missing from the jar. There are three suspects: the cat, the dog and the rabbit. Exactly one of them did it, and exactly one of them tells the truth. The other two are lying.
- Cat: “It was the rabbit.”
- Dog: “It wasn’t the rabbit.”
- Rabbit: “It wasn’t the cat.”
Try it yourself first. You only need one thought to get started.
Spoilers below
Scroll on once you have solved it, or if you want to see how the trick works.
Solution
Step 1: look at what is certain. The cat says “it was the rabbit” and the dog says “it wasn’t the rabbit”. Those two sentences are each other’s opposite. So one is true and the other is false, whatever really happened.
Step 2: count the truths. Only one suspect tells the truth, and that one is already the cat or the dog. So the rabbit is lying.
Step 3: use the lie. The rabbit says “it wasn’t the cat”. That is a lie, so it was the cat.
Check. Suppose it was the cat. The cat says “the rabbit”: false. The dog says “not the rabbit”: true. The rabbit says “not the cat”: false. Exactly one truth, as the puzzle demands.
So it was the cat. We used the trick almost invisibly there. Let us make it visible with the other two suspects:
- What if it was the dog? Then “it wasn’t the rabbit” is true, and so is “it wasn’t the cat”. Two truths, where only one is allowed. Clash: so not the dog.
- What if it was the rabbit? Then “it was the rabbit” is true, and so is “it wasn’t the cat”. Two truths again. Clash: so not the rabbit.
One suspect is left. We also had a small computer program check all three possibilities: only the cat fits every condition.
When to use it
It works best when:
- You are stuck. No clue gives you anything directly any more.
- There are few options. With two or three possibilities, “what if” is quickly done.
- You can follow the consequences. Do not take too many steps at once; stop as soon as you see a clash.
One warning: if your assumption does not clash, that proves nothing yet. You only know it is still possible. Only when every other option clashes does the last one stand.
In Petuko
In Petuko an animal sometimes could be in two places. Put it down in one of them for a moment, follow the alibis and see whether anyone ends up in a knot. If so, you know for certain the animal was not there. No guessing, just reasoning.
Want to try it? Play the first case of Petuko for free in your browser.